Evaluating Culture

1. Front Matter

   Pages i-xi

   PDF

2. Introduction

   • Matthew Thomas Johnson

   Pages 1-12

3. The Case Against Cultural Evaluation: Relativism, Culturalism and Romanticism

   • Matthew Thomas Johnson

   Pages 13-41

4. Needs, Goods and Self-Actualization

   • Matthew Thomas Johnson

   Pages 42-71

5. Capabilities, Zero-Sum Choices, Equality and Scope

   • Matthew Thomas Johnson

   Pages 72-96

6. What Is Culture? What Does It Do? What Should It Do?

   • Matthew Thomas Johnson

   Pages 97-119

7. Circumstance, Materialism and Possibilism

   • Matthew Thomas Johnson

   Pages 120-141

8. Applying the Theory: Sources of Harm in Aboriginal Australian Communities

   • Matthew Thomas Johnson

   Pages 142-167

9. Conclusion

   • Matthew Thomas Johnson

   Pages 168-173

10. Back Matter

    Pages 174-204

    PDF

From which evaluative base should we develop policies designed to promote wellbeing among different cultural groups in varying circumstances? This book engages with needs and capabilities to advance normative functionalist assessment of the success with which cultural institutions promote eudaemonic wellbeing in given, determinate circumstances.

• culture
• Design
• evaluation
• Institution

Johnson's book is a challenging and highly controversial defence of cultural evaluation. Its philosophical range is exceptionally wide, while its political engagement is informed and sophisticated. Focusing on the case of Aboriginal Australians, Johnson shows both the need for cultural evaluation and the dangers of intervention. This is a book which will be read with profit by anyone working on the politics of cultural diversity.

Sue Mendus, Department of Politics, University of York, UK

This book is remarkable in its ambition. By suggesting an objective basis on which cultures might be evaluated, it seeks to advocate interventions that prevent serious damage to human well-being. This provocative and insightful argument will stimulate significant debate as we grapple with a rapidly globalising world in which different cultures become increasingly intertwined.

Shane O'Neill, School of Politics, International Studies and Philosophy, Queen's University Belfast, UK

Evaluating cultures is one of the most complex and controversial tasks of our age. In examining how we should tackle it, Matthew Johnson's ambitious and carefully crafted study provides answers that are unusually bold in content and wide-ranging in scope. His book is essential reading for all who have to grapple with the phenomenon of culture and its significance for human wellbeing.

Peter Jones, School of Geography, Politics and Sociology, University of Newcastle, UK.

• University of York, UK

  Matthew Thomas Johnson

Matthew Johnson is a British Academy Postdoctoral Fellow at the University of York, UK working in political philosophy on issues of cultural diversity and human wellbeing, specifically with regard to physically invasive practices. He has written on such topics as contemporary Marxism, circumcision, and the thought of John Gray, and has previously taught at Newcastle University, the University of Queensland and the University of Iceland.

Policies and ethics